Chockstone Forum

      Sponsored By
      ROCK
   HARDWARE

Chockstone Photography

Australian Landscape Prints

Chockstone Forum - General Discussion

General Climbing Discussion

Topic Date User

When is a project open? 10-Nov-2004 At 7:54:06 PM Ronny

Message

>rod seems to be hoggin
>all the common sense

Not entirely convinced...yet.
There are two issues here, firstly why projects should be projects at all, and second assuming they should be, how long do they stay projects for.

Neil, on the first one I think its pretty clear that if the equipper gets something out of climbing a route for the first time like a sense of discovery, enjoyment from working something out for your self, then its hard to argue that if they put the effort in to equip a route they shouldn't be allowed to get this...within reason - see issue 2.
This seems to break down a bit when you've let someone else try the route, show you the moves, but pull on a few draws to leave the 1st accent for you.

> who had the bigger ego problem, the original person who bolted, cleaned the >route...or the person who "had" to jump on for the first send against equipers >wishes???
If we've established that the ego reasoning for the project rules doesn't work in the first place, then snaking a route to stroke your ego is obviously not on. But what about when the person just thought the route looked cool and wanted to climb it - your point doesn't really work there, and we're back to the above.

I think the second issue is much murkier - i'm not going anywhere near it, only to say that if i keep any routes i bolt to the flinders rangers where not too many ppl go anyway i probably won't encounter this problem anyway.
(du)Ron