On 11/09/2012 Cliff D wrote: 
> 
>Good point! How can a climb be "great" if the rock is shit, and you may 
>as well be walking up stairs because all the moves are boring, and you 
>may as well be soloing because the pro sucks? long climb or not! 
 
I don't know - committment? Exposure? Makes up for a lot of crap. 
 
Anyway, Quality is subjective, but it helps to assess with objective criteria. 
 
E.g. 
 
One star - I lead the climb. 
Two star - I lead the climb, and didn't fall off. 
Three star - I lead the climb, didn't fall off, but my partner did. |