Chockstone Forum

      Sponsored By
      ROCK
   HARDWARE

Chockstone Photography

Australian Landscape Prints

Chockstone Forum - General Discussion

General Climbing Discussion

Topic Date User

History Rewritten on first 23 in Australia 21-May-2018 At 12:32:44 PM Jayford4321

Message

On 21-May-2018 tastrad wrote:
>For the last 43 years it has been assumed that Henry Barber introduced
>grade 23 to Australia, officially Insomnia at Frog being the first one...though
>Kama Sutra at Araps on the same trip is harder. In researching a new book
>I'm writing on the history of Tasmanian climbing, I have discovered that
>Ian Lewis had free climbed Albatross at Lowdina near Hobart in 1974, before
>Hot Henry came in 1975. The guidebook credits Lewis with the first ascent,
>but gives the first free ascent to Henry, as it was reported that Lewis
>had a point of aid (rest) on his ascent. In recent interviews for the book,
>both Ian Lewis and his belayer Lyle Closs are adamant that it was done
>free. Albatross was the only route Henry Barber fell off on his Australian
>trip. I've been on it, and not many would argue with grade 24..its desperate.
>So there you go... Ian Lewis did the first grade 23 in Australia in 1974.

So why did it take so long?
If the FAs reckoned other than the way it was written up it should have been corrected in subsequent guidebooks.
Sounds a bit like a retro to me.
What do you reckon KC would think of this new revision thing?