Chockstone Forum

      Sponsored By
      ROCK
   HARDWARE

Chockstone Photography

Australian Landscape Prints

Chockstone Forum - General Discussion

General Climbing Discussion

Author

Interesting article on bolts in QLD National Parks

nmonteith

28-Jan-2013
12:24:03 PM

http://www.qldclimb.org.au/2012/12/commentary-on-nprsr-operational-policy-rock-climbing-on-qpws-managed-areas/

Olbert

28-Jan-2013
3:20:15 PM

In 2012 NPWS wrote:
>6.1 QPWS acknowledges that permanent fixed protection and other permanent climb aids >(including anchors and chains) already exist at many sites within QPWS managed areas >and that these are necessary for maintaining a range of climbing opportunities.

So they acknowledge that bolts exist and are necessary for climbing. What does that mean for litigation because of bolt failure? What does that mean for the placing of new bolts?

davidn

28-Jan-2013
4:48:45 PM

See how many stacked negatives and vagueisms you can find in this sentence:

"As a general proposition, it is arguable that in some cases the risk that a bolt may fail in the absence of negligence by anyone is an inherent risk of climbing."

Good on you, Gordon Brysland - you constructed a sentence that no one but a lawyer could parse. I write for a living, but you've defeated me!

If I had to paraphrase, I'd try the following:
"Bolts can fail, like anyone can fall off a set of ranger-constructed stairs, but that doesn't mean the person setting up the permanent fixture is to blame."

Jayford4321

31-Jan-2013
3:33:40 PM

On 28/01/2013 stugang wrote:
>Good on you, Gordon Brysland - you constructed a sentence that no one
>but a lawyer could parse. I write for a living, but you've defeated me!

Not hard to do.
>
>If I had to paraphrase, I'd try the following:
>"Bolts can fail, like anyone can fall off a set of ranger-constructed
>stairs, but that doesn't mean the person setting up the permanent fixture
>is to blame."

Thats a typically stupid statement about bolted climbing by someone who typically only boulders and knows climbing mostly from youtube and climbing forums.
Ever hear about the croat route near bunny bucket butress?
Do some homework and get back to us with an apology.

shiltz

31-Jan-2013
4:37:03 PM

I'm confused...
Did stugang post on 28/1/2013 or ratherbeclimbinV9?
Or is ratherbeclimbinV9 trying to start a debate with ratherbeclimbinV9?
Does anyone care?

nmonteith

31-Jan-2013
8:23:56 PM

They are different people - one is an imposter, with a full stop after the username.

IdratherbeclimbingM9

31-Jan-2013
8:59:18 PM

On 31/01/2013 nmonteith wrote:
>They are different people - one is an imposter, with a full stop after the username.

The ID's are all over the shop again...
At least one of the above V9's is davidn, stugang is currently Eduardo Slabovic, and Eduardo Slabofvic is currently stugang. and was also Spugang recently.

There are others who currently operate under different user ID's to what they started out as on this site as well, but their current monikers are relatively stable!

There are 7 messages in this topic.